Customer Loyalty

by Mr. Cheap

For a while I was trying to launch a consulting / contracting career where I’d go and work on-site doing technical work for companies for a few weeks at a time then move on to the next place. I read everything I could get my hands on about consulting, especially technical consulting. One idea I came across that I thought was great was that of “The Warm Fuzzy Feeling“. He has a bunch of great suggestions on the page I’ve linked to, but I think there’s an overriding idea. Your job, when you’re providing services for money, is to make sure the customer isn’t worried. If you accomplish this, anything else is minor details.

I recently flew out to Edmonton to visit the university there. My flight was before the subway started running in the morning, so I had to book a car to take me to the airport. I called the lowest priced place I could find on Google (hey, I’m Mr. Cheap remember?) and the guy who answered had a thick accent. I explained when my flight was, and where I was going (domestic, not international) and asked him what time he’d recommend a pick up for. He asked me what time I wanted to be picked up. I repeated where I was going, and asked him what he recommended to make sure I arrive on time. He said that they just picked up customers at whatever time the customer wanted.

At this point I’m having visions of panicking on the morning of my flight when no car shows up and I politely got off the phone with him and called the next lowest bidder. The woman who answered spoke clearly, immediately told me a time (and broke down how she got to that time in terms of traffic in the early morning and processing time for domestic flights). She said she goes out to Edmonton all the time, and says she always gets through the security check quickly. She recommended that I check out the casino while I’m out there.

I’m feeling the warm fuzzies. I book a wake up call from them (as a back up in case my three alarms fail) and am quite confident they’re going to get me to my flight. I compliment her (she encouraged me to call her boss and talk to him).

The morning of the flight, no wake up call. Fuzzies are dropping. I call the company and tell them I didn’t get a wake up call. The gentleman on the other end tells me my pick up time. I repeat that I was supposed to get a wake up call and didn’t and I just want to be sure that the car is coming. He tells me that there’s nothing in my file about a wake up call (no fuzzies). The car did come, and the driver was amazing, chatty and engaging the whole trip. Fuzzies were coming back. At the airport, I was planning to give him a pretty nice tip, and when he gives me the bill, its $10 more than quoted (fuzzies gone again). He was a nice guy and he gave me the quoted rate (after I made sure it wouldn’t come out of his pocket – I still gave him the tip I was planning on).

This company could have had a customer for life if they had just got the wake up call and the price right. Sometimes things go wrong (I understand that) and if they’d just immediately apologized for not making the wake up call and promised to look into it (lie to me, that’s ok) I’d have been fine too. They’ve got a service running at 99% of amazing, and then they screw it up. Stop offering wake up calls if you can’t make them reliably. Raise the rates you’re quoting people (I HATE when companies try to change what they’re billing me without warning).

Companies often look at providing the minimum acceptable service, arguing with customers about what is reasonable or not, or they look at changing things only when tons of people complain. I think the article I linked to hits on something of value when it talks about going beyond that. Smooth out the rough edges and get rid of the things that irritate customers (but not enough that they complain). Occasionally get a friend to use your service as an outsider and tell you how you can improve.

To clarify, I’m NOT saying “do whatever the customer wants at whatever price he wants to pay”. I’m saying keep an eye on the customer experience at your company, and continually remove things that irritate or worry them.

It always amazes me how companies market so aggressively (if you go on Google car rides to the Toronto airport seems to be a fairly competitive market), but then they couldn’t care less about your experience as a customer (which will determine whether you use them or a competitor in the future).

A book also along these lines is “Raving Fans” by Ken Blanchard and Sheldon Bowles.

Be Sociable, Share!

Want to learn more about RESPs? Buy The Book:

Resp-Book

The RESP Book: The Simple Guide to Registered Education Savings Plans

Everything you need to know about RESPs.

See it on Amazon now

{ 7 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Matt

A lot of people will market and sell themselves to the Nth degree but when it comes to actually providng you with the service that they offered initially they are no where to be found.

I ran into some great customer service from Dell lately. I had a weird issue and the gentleman from India stayed on the phone with me for close to two hours trying to figure it out. He made it his mission to try resolving the issue and being polite about it answering my silly questions in the process. I’ll definitely buy from them again.

Getting the business isn’t the goal… having it come back over and over again is

2 Quietrose

Great post Mr. C! Thanks for the link to the article about “warm fuzzies.” I’ve passed it onto a few friends of mine, so thanks! As a small business owner, I agree with a lot of the points in the article. People want and deserve good customer service and to not provide that as a business owner is definitely not wise, in fact, it is detrimental to your business goals.

3 growthinvalue

I had to book a car to take me to the airport

For some reason, it took me about 6 paragraphs to figure out what you meant by this. The way it’s written, I assumed you were renting a car (like from Discount or Budget or Enterprise or something) but from the sounds of it, you were basically getting a taxi, right?

That said, the crux of your piece is bang-on: customer experience is drastically underestimated, so I also find it odd that companies are willing to spend billions in advertising to get me to use their product once, but don’t lift a finger to make sure I’ll use it countless times again in my life.

4 Four Pillars

Matt – you are right, but good to hear about the unusual service from Dell!

QR – we all deserve some customer service.

GIV – Hey, where have you been??

5 Mr. Cheap

GIV: sorry that phrase threw you. Yes, basically its like a taxi (except you book them ahead of time and pay a flat rate).

6 TFB

The thing is if they didn’t have the 2nd lowest price on Google, you wouldn’t have called them in the first place and you wouldn’t have experienced their 99% amazing service. So they can’t really raise their price quote. Companies offering better service should be able to charge more. But in this case they can’t.

7 Mr. Cheap

TFB: True enough. I guess it depends where in its lifecycle the company is. If it has a reliable number of loyal customers, it can gradually increase its rates (always making sure that they’re gaining customers faster than they’re losing them). If they’re in a high growth mode, unfortunately providing excellent service at a reasonable price is the only way they’re going to attract (and keep) customers.

My two complaints wouldn’t cost them a cent to fix, it would just take a willingness on their part to acknowledge the problem and fix it. Sadly most small businesses would rather argue with soon-to-be-ex-customers rather than embrace the opportunity to improve.

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: