Book Review: Outliers by Malcolm Gladwell

by Mr. Cheap

Welcome to Money Smarts! If you're new here, please read the "About" page to find out more about this site. If you would like to receive updates by email then sign up here or you can subscribe to the RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!

I first heard about Malcolm Gladwell’s new book, “Outliers: The Story of Success” about a month ago and was delighted that he was putting out a new book. I was wildly enthusiastic about “Blink” and “The Tipping Point” and after reading an extract online I couldn’t wait. By a happy coincidence, a friend gave me an early Christmas gift, and it was Outliers!

In “Blink” Gladwell looked at very fast cognition (things your brain processes in the blink of an eye). In “The Tipping Point” he looked at what led to ideas propagating and spreading through society (why some take off and why some die). In this book he looks at incredibly successful people (they’re the outliers) and argues that there’s more behind their success than the myth society tells us about them (that they’re naturally brilliant & gifted).

As with all of Gladwell’s work, he’s a delight to read. He takes an interesting idea, chews away at it, and presents his thoughts, building a surprising, yet plausible, model around them. In “Freakanomics” they debunked one of the big ideas he argued for in “The Tipping Point”, so that’s the one danger of Gladwell’s work: he’s very persuasive, even when he’s wrong.

The idea behind this work is that people who are great at something (we’re talking world class talent) are great primarily because of the time they’ve invested, rather than an inherent ability. A certain threshold of “raw ability” is necessary (which is lower than you’d think), but beyond that it’s often luck whether they managed to accumulate the time required to become world-class. The time investment, he argues, that’s needed is 10,000 hours, and its often circumstance that determines whether someone who has the interest to invest that amount of time is also given the opportunity.

He gives examples supporting this from violinists at an elite Berlin music academy, Canadian hockey players, high-tech entrepreneurs, and the Beatles (apparently they’re some minstrels from England achieved a bit of fame a long time ago).

Following up on the lucky circumstances, he also builds the case that even a small lucky break early on compounds as someone who has shown an “early aptitude” is given more opportunities, which leads to an increase in aptitude, in a reinforcing cycle until they accumulate the hours to become good or extraordinary at something. He argues that the reason Chinese people are often good at math is because Mandarin has a cleaner, more regular syntax for naming numbers. This gives young Chinese students a leg up when they first start learning math, and they’re able to build on this lead (and have a positive first experience with the subject).

He presents counter examples of Lewis Terman’s study of high IQ students (they tracked the top 1% of the top 1%) in California, who didn’t really amount to much as a group (and even within the group, socio-economic status was a better indicator of success than their IQ). Terman’s study rejected two boys as not smart enough to participate who went on to win Nobel prizes.

The take-aways from the book were that if you want to be really good at something, you’ve got to put in the time (along with meeting SOME requirements, you’ll never play in the NBA if you 5’3). You’re fooling yourself if you think you’ll just naturally be world class at something. The trick is to keep practising, and the people who will excel are those who find the motivation to keep at it. If you want to excel in your profession, put in the time at the activities that are important to it. If you want to learn a new skill, put in the hours of study and practising. There’s no royal road to excellence.

I highly recommend putting this book on your Christmas (or Hanukkah, or winter’s solstice) list. Its a fun, fast read.

I kept wondering if he’d mention an age limit, but he didn’t, so maybe it’s still possible for me to get cracking on my 10,000 hours and win a gold metal in Olympic gymnastics!

Be Sociable, Share!

Want to learn more about RESPs? Buy The Book:

Resp-Book

The RESP Book: The Simple Guide to Registered Education Savings Plans

Everything you need to know about RESPs.

See it on Amazon now

Welcome to Money Smarts! If you're new here, please read the "About" page to find out more about this site. If you would like to receive updates by email then sign up here or you can subscribe to the RSS feed. Thanks for visiting!

{ 8 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Four Pillars

To be honest, I haven’t read any of his books but based on this review I definitely will.

2 Mike

I highly recommend all three of his books with one word of warning. As mentioned in the post, Gladwell is very convincing. Be his arguments right or wrong, he does present a great other perspective that is worth listening/reading. He might not always be right, but he is worth your time as he’ll presnt some wonderful arguments that will cause you to pause and think – which is what I think makes him a valuable author. He spurs the thought process.

3 Jordan

He reads his own audiobooks too and does a pretty good job of it.

Thanks for the review I’ll be listening to it soon!

4 sundae1888

His books were well-written, but I always find them standing on less-than-concrete grounds.

BTW, as an avid basketball fan, I must correct you on not being able to play in the NBA if you’re 5’3″. It has been done before by Muggsy Bogues (played in the league 1987-2001), although one ought to be an EXCEPTIONAL basketball player to compensate the height disadvantage. He is probably the best 5’3″ basketball player ever.

5 Mr. Cheap

Sundae,

As you caught me, I don’t know anything about basketball. I was originally going to write 5’6, then I thought “maybe there’s been a crazy good 5’6 player, guaranteed no one 5’3 or lower has ever played in the NBA”.

Thanks for setting me straight!

6 Mike

I just finished this book – fantastic! I’m going to read his other two books fairly soon.

I would add that I think he does say you need some skill and some natural ability to be really good but without the 10,000 hours then it won’t happen.

7 Mr. Cheap

Hey Mike: Glad you read it and enjoyed it. I actually had set aside my copy for you, but never actually gave it to you (even though we’ve got together twice since I wrote this I think).

Sorry about that (and I’m happy you got a copy).

8 Mike

No problem Mr. Cheap – we got it from the library.

Leave a Comment

Current ye@r *

Previous post:

Next post: